Consortial Networks and Publishers: Partnering in a Sea of Competition
Monday, March 17, 2008
It is no secret: libraries face daily and ever-increasing competition. Within this sea of competition, however, publishers and regionally-based consortial networks are forging partnerships to develop creative, long-term cost-effective business models for content delivery.
Where is the competition coming from?
Competition for traditional library services is coming from all directions, but most obviously from the web, where consumer information is widely available and in many cases freely accessible. Wikipedia, for all its faults, has become a destination reference resource while other less well-branded sources of information are made easily discoverable by search services such as Google. Thus users are now able to self-serve much of the information that historically has only been available via the library or other paid services. But, of course, users are largely untrained in the skills of assessing found materials for authoritativeness, and in forgoing library assistance they are at risk not only of missing out on valuable paid-for resources, but also of basing their studies on incorrect data or ill-formed arguments. The convenience of internet research is substituting for the credible sources to be obtained from the traditional library.
What effect does this new competition have?
Historically, libraries have had the good fortune of being a monopoly; if you wanted access to information, especially authoritative information, you went to the library. Libraries had no competition and thus had no need to operate like a commercial business. As other resources become more prominent, libraries are having to re-envision and re-tool to operate in a more competitive environment. This is an attitudinal shift to which not all librarians are ready to adapt; the rigours of competition in a free market are not necessarily a welcome environment for those who have opted for an altruistic career assisting researchers in their information quest.
Some people's reaction to the sea of competition?
How can libraries reinforce their value in the information supply chain?
Researchers continue to need to access quality, peer-reviewed information, and in providing this the library is making itself an essential tool in the academic arsenal. Libraries should take advantage of regional networks like Amigos and Palinet that can help by promoting libraries as information providers and community leaders, and by facilitating sharing of resources and development of innovative services. Networks may also be able to negotiate discounts of which members can take advantage when purchasing scholarly content from publishers or aggregators.
If you are attending ER&L, be sure to attend this session in order to add your voice to the discussion. If you would like to arrange an appointment with Jeff Downing during the event, please contact jeff.downing@ingenta.com - or stop by the Ingenta table at the sponsors' reception tomorrow night.
Labels: consortia, erl, Google, libraries, research, wikipedia
posted by Charlie Rapple at 5:34 pm
![]()
Latest issue of our library newsletter is now live
- an update on IngentaConnect's online advertising activities: where you might see ads, what they look like, how we select and control them
- details of the events we'll be attending and speaking at during 2008
- starting soon with Jeff Downing's paper on the value offered by consortial networks in an increasingly competitive library landscape, which he will present at the Electronic Resources & Libraries (ER&L) conference in Atlanta at the end of this month
- a reminder piece about the structure of Ingenta's library services, following significant changes during the last year
- an overview of industry initiatives including KBART, COUNTER, Transfer and MESUR and how these impact our work and that of our customers
- details of the 10 latest publishers to join IngentaConnect:
- Acta Ichthyologica et Piscatoria
- American Association for Laboratory Animal Science
- Essential Oil Resource Consultants SARL
- Hellenic Veterinary Medical Society
- Institut National d’Etudes Démographiques
- Journal of Spatial Science
- The Institute of Marine Engineering, Science and Technology (IMarEST)
- The International Association for Language Learning Technology
- Nordic Board for Wildlife Research
- Oxbow Books
- news of Jeff Downing and Becky Lenzini's appointments (already covered on the blog a few weeks ago)
- special offers from our publisher partners to our library customers.
Labels: "online advertising", counter, erl, eyetoeye, ingentaconnect, kbart, mesur, publishers, RSS, transfer
posted by Charlie Rapple at 2:59 pm
![]()


